The half is indeed an AU-58. When it went to the coin shop one day I was offered first refusal on it, another buyer in the store ready to buy it, credit cards in hand if I passed up. I couldn't with that lovely color and great details.
Nice, looks like I was a little tough on that one. And I know what you mean, nobody in my family cares, they all say "Don't you already have that one" or "They all look the same" :/ At least I have y'all! lol
It might, but I don't like playing that game. I see wear, I know its an honest AU coin and thats how it will stay while I've got it.