Guess the Grade Medieval Gold Edition

Same denomination and type. Let's see how many here have what it takes to match NGC's skill

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

First coin AU,

Second coin MS?

 

I don't put much weight behind number grades, but it is a gorgeous coin!

 

wow! those look amazing. I would not know how to grade these.

 

Pretty simple to me.

A+ with the red circle smiley face and maybe a sticker with "great job" on it.

 

I meant to say those are very beautiful.

 

Beautifull Chaise d'or coins from Louis de Male/ Flanders/ Ghent Mint
I would say first coin AU-55 second one MS-64. Here is mine/ from Kunker Auction/ graded as "fast stempelglanz=AU"

 

Geez, if that second coin is only an MS-64 I would send it back and hold out for a 65. LOL.

 

Beautiful coin Panzerman! Yours is truly a lovely example.

Both coins I have shown have been graded ms 62 by NGC but overall I agree with the grades you assigned. The 2nd example is by far superior to the 1st in every way and the price both coins sold for reflected that

Another example of the importance of buying the coin and not the slab!

 

Where they both graded are around the same time? Can you tell with NGC by the holder like you can with PCGS? If they are not then that could account for the difference.

 

First coin AU 58, second MS 62