Guess the grade #458

1946-D NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

VERY rich color MS-67RD

..btw a grade if '6262' might blow away many collectors, I mean, almost 100x the best grade of MS-70..phew

 

67, solid.

 

I should probably check the pops to be safe, but that coin sure looks like a 67 to me, so that's what I graded it.

 

Haha Leadfoot you are in the battle for your life here I'm just trying to hang in the top 10 (but it does appear to be a 67, and the fact that it's NGC helps!)

 

I've had to up my game! Irish and Duke and ldbair (and, frankly, lots of folks) are very good graders indeed.

 

Very nice....easy one.

 

67rd

 

ms-67rd here

 

MS67 rd

I kinda cheated though. I used the online PCGS photo grade to confirm my guess.

 

67 on this one

 

I went with 67 as well. Nice coin. Has NGC ever gave a 68 on one of these?

 

67

 

Gotta go with ms67rd

 

Wow , I'd give it the 68 but I'll guess 67 .

 

Thats a solid 67

 

I know what you mean , there's some tough competition . I'm happy just being in the middle , but I have my sights on you Mike , after all you and rlm taught me most of what I know about grading MS cents .

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t220957/ will be ending tonight!

 

Did not challenge too many here. It is all there - luster, strike, lack of distractions, etc. Yes. it is a 67 and a pretty nice one.

 

Shook things up a bit this round and we have a newcomer in MNcoinman. You needed some competition, right? Irish2Ice is still the leader, but he is slowly coming back to the pack.

Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.

1. Irish2Ice 0.297 39
2. Leadfoot 0.313 34
3. Duke Kavanaugh 0.381 22
4. MNcoinman 0.421 20
5. ldhair 0.423 27
6. BadThad 0.435 48
7. rzage 0.457 48
8. mark_h 0.488 45
9. bahabully 0.500 21
10. pumpkinpie 0.515 35