This and http://www.cointalk.com/t207750/ will be ending tonight. Assuming I can add pictures, I will start another round.
I swear that obverse would make a solid 67. Strike and luster are all there. There are only a couple tiny marks not visible to the naked eye. The reverse has the strike and luster, but also a couple small ticks and a couple spots. I wish I knew what it was like when they graded it. Without that spot, it would easily make a 66 and possibly a 67. However, NGC only gave it a 65. BTW Everyone please take note! Doug finally over-graded one.
ldhair still leads and Leadfoot coming up behind, but we finally got the pot stirring a bit. Lincoln Cents joined the top in at the #4 position. Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses. ldhair 0.400 37 Leadfoot 0.424 35 Shoewrecky 0.440 26 Lincoln Cents 0.474 20 BadThad 0.500 46 Irish2Ice 0.500 44 bahabully 0.571 29 jcakcoin 0.587 48 rzage 0.605 40 Cazkaboom 0.609 48