Guess the grade #357

1923- NGC slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

This is close between a 64/65. I'm struggling on this one. I'm going to say 65.

 

MS66 RB, I would grade it 65 however

 

I'm stuck between 65 and 66 .

 

There are some significant nicks on the shoulder as well as the reverse writing. I'm going to go 64.

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t205597/ will be ending tonight. New rounds will be posted, but how much analysis remains to be determined.

 

On the fence b/t 64/65........

 

OMG! Only 8 responders?
Another one of those where the photograph emphasizes the nicks. Yes. they are there, but they are very hard to see in hand. The same can be said for the spots. This is a nice strike and color with minimal nicks. I personally think it would have a good shot at a 66 were it not for the spots. NGC said 65. All-in-all, I could settle for that.

Standings later.

 

Jez, I missed 2 rounds, I never even saw this post. LOL

 

Dang and I voted 65 , must have forgot to hit the post button . Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr