Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="Breakdown, post: 918515, member: 19532"]To be clear and not to get in the middle, both Doug and Paul seem to be drawing conclusions from the poll, in part by using my MS65FS vote (as well as Green18's) as an anomaly to support their arguments that most people would not grade the coin MS65.  However, I made clear I was voting what I thought PCGS graded the coin. Would I give it a 65 if I started the JGS (Jeff's Grading Service)? Of course not. It would probably be a 62 or 63. Most people apparently voted what they would grade it themselves. But that was not the question in Paul's poll. If anyone doesn't believe me, check the first post. It states, "Guess the assigned grade of this 1974 Jefferson Nickel graded by PCGS." If you want to draw conclusions from the poll, it is either (A) most people ignored Paul's actual question or (B) most people were unable to accurately guess what PCGS's assigned grade was.:smile<img src="styles/default/xenforo/clear.png" class="mceSmilieSprite mceSmilie1" alt=":)" unselectable="on" unselectable="on" /> By the way, the two of you need to stay friendly as your debates are providing good info to the rest of us. :hammer::hammer:[/QUOTE]