Guess the Grade - 1885-S Morgan

63 PL

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Old PCGS Gen. 1 holder MS 62 not PL

 

Looks like a rattler I think. Grade today is 64/5 obv PL/DMPL

 

MS 64+

 

@jtlee321 was the closest to the holder and @dwhiz nailed the grade.

In my opinion, the coin looks like an MS 64 and is PL only on the obverse (so maybe star worthy if it was in an NGC holder).

 

So you agree with my grade assessment and I got the holder lol..

I knew exactly what the generation of holder was, just was not absolute on which label it was.

 

I think Resubmition would get you another point. Don't know if a point would be worth it,
So what's the point

 

What he want's is a gold bean on the Doily holder. That's the real winning combo. That's what I would be doing with it.

 

At the moment I will be leaving it as is. I collect holders and Morgans, so this is a great combination for me!

I have never submitted to CAC (am not a member). Resubmitting would not be worth it unless it came back MS 65 (I paid above MS 63 levels and MS 64 would just mean breaking even after all the fees and losing the doily holder).

 

I would never crack that baby out. The holder itself add's probably $100.00 to the price at least. You add on a gold CAC sticker and you can charge nearly 65 money for it. Especially if in person. It's a beauty.

 

CAC now!

 

Maybe ebay first
Maybe at some point it'll go to CAC.

 

I'm down to send her into CAC for you bro...I will be sending some coins in within the next month or so. I am collector-member there so no cost if no sticker

 

WOW I am floored. At least a 64 ..

 

With todays gradeflation it's a 64. Back then 62 all day.
I would award it one of my special stickers.

 

Moose bacon?

 

Why not