I haven't read any replies yet, but it seems proof. They are extremely hard to photograph. I voted cameo though.
Late to the party @Pickin and Grinin but I saw the tag in the 84-O thread RE: images: If I collected proofs I would invest in an axial setup as I’ve never seen a normal setup that captures them right; trying to capture cameo or toning without it seems darn near impossible but perhaps others have found workarounds. I’d say you captured it pretty well considering. Sweet coin!
I think I would have been able to get better photos had the coin been raw. The slab just gets in the way. Agreed that an Axial set up is the way to go. I have been reading and watching some videos on easy set ups.