Based on the pics, I like this one at 58. This is exactly the type of coin that would be in a 62 slab, however - the typical AU-62.
You're the only one who got this one coin looks much more like the first pics in hand not as dark as this one
Definitely a choice AU-55 as far as details are concerned. Luster looked AU-53, while detail looked AU-58. This is one of the more-accurately graded coins from this hoard.
I bought quite a few from the hoard. Nearly every one had or now has a cac sticker. This I think the only one that doesn't except for the 74-s trade I cracked out to deal with pvc on it then sent to pcgs where it downgraded from 55-53. I was fine with that. It hasn't gone to cac where it may likely bean at 53. I'm very tempted to crack this one and send to pcgs especially to lose the 57 st holder
Bought this one for my type set a couple years ago thought it was a good original example and the money was right. I'm completely content with a nice original au on this and a lot of other issues and would rather spend the big dollars on rarities and coins with exceptional eye appeal.