Not sure what the mark on the face is damage a planchet flaw or just a spot but it really bothered me too bad as it's a beautiful coin
Scrape on the reverse? All I see are lines at 9-10 o'clock, just left of 12 o'clock, and 1-2 o'clock; I had guessed those might be die cracks.
I think the 10 o clock is a scratch there's a bruise at the rim and it follows it I could be wrong not seeing in hand but that's how I read it
It's not that I disagree because it's ICG, some of my best coins are in ICG holders. Are the 1916 Merc's known for weak strikes?