Hard to tell what is on plastic or coin, especially with dark toning. Given I see three hits on shield, one on tail feathers, and a couple on the obverse I went 64.
You're right about that, Scott. Due to the fuzziness when enlarged I think it's nearly impossible to tell if there's any wear. But hey, we take them as we find them. So I'll notice a few deep contact marks on the shield and tail, and another just under the sideburn. The TPGs are pretty strict on these, principally because they were kept from the start, and not a whole lot circulated. I'm going guess the marks are going to hurt it, and they gave it a 63 to 64. I checked 64 in your poll.
Hard to tell, as was said due to fuzziness in the enlarged photo. I will guess about 64. The toning is not particularly appealing to me.
Yeah, I was up in the air on the toning, but I was already paying shipping on others, so I put a winning bid on it. I didn't care for it at first, but it has grown on me. Strange, huh?