Only 1 had the grade right, and then he changed his grade. The light circ marks have to be looked for on this one. She is well struck and has a light pastel ring from 3 to 7 on the obverse. @longshot
Tough one. I wouldn't have argued with either 58 or low mint state. Do you agree with the grade in hand, @Pickin and Grinin ?
I don't see any evidence of wear in either the original photos or the slab photo, are there some hairlines that aren't showing up in the photos?
Personally, I don't think that they were all that tough on it. They definitely used everybit of the ANA grading standards on this one. I have seen MS64's with more hairlines than there are on this coin, and you really have to look for them. Look at the cheek in the first photo. That is the extent of the hairlines. They are slightly cross hatched and extremely light.