Here is another I picked up at the NWCC show this past weekend. Vote in the poll as to what you think the NGC slab calls out for a grade. Have a crack at the Overton as well if you are so inclined and put that in a reply. All comments welcome. I will do the reveal tomorrow.
I voted 53. It would be higher if the luster is good, but the photo is not showing it. If the luster is strong, it’s a 55 or 58.
I voted 53 even though I thought it could easily be a 55 for the same reasons @johnmilton gave regarding luster. Last night at my local coin club meeting, I showed the photo to another member who is a long-time member of the Bust Half Nut Club. After hemming and hawing around for a while, he finally said it could be in a range of 53 to 58 depending on the presence or absence of luster which he could not determine from the photographs, even though he rotated my phone around in the prescribed manner - Ha! Ha!.
