I was wavering between 55 and 58, both of which were wrong, but I agree they were a bit grumpy that day. Nice coin.
Wow, that shows how an image can represent/misrepresent a coin. In the first picture, I see it as a gorgeous AU-58. In the last picture, in the slab, I see it as a dipped-out AU-50.
First glance was a higher grade, then I realized the coin wasn't very lustrous and had a lot of contact marks. That's why I said AU50.