Nice. Looks like a 1a. Love that girl. I have a thing for heavily scrubbed dies and both sides of 1a have been hit hard by the brillo pad. Check out the 1a page. Messydesk did a cool looking gif on this one
Sorry guy's I just finished a 14 hour day on my feet walking around on concrete shooting state high school wrestling tournament. I'll post the answer in the morning. Sorry for the delay.
Sorry for the delay. The results are NGC MS-65. I know that hit to the neck is distracting, but the rest of it is absolutely stunning. I picked it up because of the super heavy die polishing lines. And it is VAM-1a, I knew the VAMpires would come through.
You Know? That little comment about a details grade? It took me going to VAM world to figure this out. I had thought someone might have put an eraser to that sucker. Nice Morgan!
No, it's a white crusty part of the silver. I've seen it before on lot's of other Morgan Dollars. My guess is it's part of the original planchet, that did not get fully struck out.
This one is not a particularly good strike, especially for Philadelphia, and the spot you mentioned is the very_first_place on a Morgan where a weak strike manifests. What you're seeing for "color" there is very likely the original planchet surface - it wasn't struck hard enough for any metal movement in that spot whatsoever (especially considering it's very close to the exact center of the coin).
Would you call it the same tone that is found on the stars? I call this a die state not strike evidence.
A bit surprised about the grade. The luster must have bumped it up on this one, because it seems really nice and frosty. 1903 is typically quite well struck, and this one isn't. I would have been torn about buying this one. Really cool VAM, but perhaps overgraded. In-hand may be a different story, of course.