Got a Carson City Eagle for my Birthday...

Yes, in Europe all slabbed coins that are MS-62/63/64/65 are graded as fast stempelglanz/ about UNC/ qFDC
Kunker even graded some MS-66 examples as fast stempelglanz! We have a Canadian TPG named "CCCS" tat grades in European style.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

You are correct, as I stated, based on the images provided we can't be assured of an under/over-grade condition. Just based on my experience, having viewed thousands of Liberty Eagle images, I just picked a current random auction superior? coin. I'd bet that the condition of his coin is equivalent or superior to the following coin, 2 grades advanced? What do you think?:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/US-Gold-10...877622?hash=item5d71b888f6:g:QA4AAOSwZTJa45W~

JMHO

 

Sounds like you found a keeper