Fresh from Sarasota- GTG 5$ Indian

We all know that the incuse design of the 2,5 and 5 $ Indian series is no easy target for grading. So I selected this 1912 Indian from my last NGC Submission to play GTG with you. Go for it, your input is welcome.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

MS-63 ? I don't know, it's gold that's all I know .

 

I'll guess at least MS-63 but no higher than MS-64.

 

62 gold is so hard im going low on it.

 

MS64

 

You are correct on gold grading, however, I will offer 64 with fingers crossed.

 

63

 

61

 

I’ve seen the submission results that’s why I’ll skip this GTG. Great coin, although I don’t agree with the assigned grade.

 

63

 

I'm at 63.

 

64.

 

Let's talk about it anyway. You could post something to throw us off.

These coins start at MS-62 if there is no obvious wear. The only "bad" thing I see but cannot be sure so I ignored it is the possible damage between star 10 & 11.

 

58 based on micbraun's comment! Otherwise 64

 

64

 

The only "bad" thing I see but cannot be sure so I ignored it is the possible damage between star 10 & 11.[/QUOTE]

Thanks,@Insider.
This is just dirt, no damage.

 

MS64

 

OK. MS66+

 

Rheingold, posted: "This is just dirt, no damage."

Does anyone else aside from me think the TPGS should have removed the dirt (w/permission) before slabbing the coin? That's the difference between a top TPGS and others.