Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="cpm9ball, post: 3346798, member: 24633"]Let me try to take a stab at this using my poor sense of logic! A die clash would be a particular stage in the lifespan of a die. Prior to the occurrence, the die might be considered flawless with some, or possibly no wear. After the clash, the condition of the die would continue to deteriorate, thus creating additional stages in its life.A die abrasion is something distinctly different from a die clash, but it still identifies a particular stage in the life of a die. While both may be considered a variety because they have altered the intended design, that is not always the case. The "42 over 41" dime can rightly be considered a variety because it was intentionally altered at the Mint. The same can be said for the "O over CC" Morgan. However, the 2005-S KS Silver SQ was originally considered a Mint Error, a "die gouge", and remained that way for about 7 years until it was changed to a "die dent" and became a variety listed in the CPG in 2012. Why? Don't ask me! Chris[/QUOTE]