Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="Aslanmia, post: 1095126, member: 11753"]The difference here is that the coin was sold as GEM BU and graded MS-65 (which I can most likely prove was slabbed by the same seller). I sent the coin to the top (arguably) coin grading company to get confirmation I got what I paid for, and not only is it not GEM BU, but it's damaged to the point it wouldn't even grade. Again, I would have been happy with an MS-60, but no such luck. The top (arguably) professionals in the field said not only was it not GEM BU as advertised (regardless of what the slab said), but that it was basically a cull coin. I hoping that is grounds enough for a "significantly not as described" claim. This is not a case of the seller's opinion of the coin vs. my opinion, it's the seller's opinion vs. PCGS's opinion. He says it's a gem example of a brilliant uncirculated coin and PCGS says it's damaged junk.[/QUOTE]