Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="Paddy54, post: 2096777, member: 19250"]Due to the fact that most all Morgans  silver dollars  were transported in 1000.00 bags and 1000 coins this size hitting  one another are going damage the next. I think this coin would grade a 64. However  I agree with Lehigh  points. This to me is a slider. High 64 low 65. The coin has great luster and PL surfaces . And again Lehigh  point where are you going to find another this date on par?I have had quite  a few Morgans in my time. Some rolls I've  had case in point a roll of 1904 O 's that had the same PL luster as well as the frosting  on the face. Most came back MS- 64 ' s maybe 3 that went 65.  But the difference  beats me as the roll was  an original  bank wrapped roll. And the end coin was toned. In the passed  sending in a Morgan  for grading most have come back 64's. And some better dates less. As grading is subjective  a point we all   can agree.... my honest opinion  is that TPG'S  are more subjective to a better date than a run of the mill date.Meaning if it's  a toss up 64/65 they are going to grade down as apposed  to up.  The coin that the original  poster put up I venture  to say that  not one of us here would be unhappy owning.[/QUOTE]