Do the red flags go up on this Seated Liberty Half?

Spotted this SLH on the Bay. Seller has zero transactions, is located in UK, and does not accept returns. There is also an odd toning on obverse and reverse, which might be due to photography. And yet people are bidding. Opinions?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

That toning is too similar to the typical Chinese fakes for me to feel comfortable.

 

It's color is the first thing that made me question it.

 

It has that brownish splotchy paint that's been more commonly seen on Chinese coins lately.

Even if it were a real coin I wouldn't buy from a seller with those credentials.

 

Everything about it screams Chinese counterfeit.

 

Chinese date digits

 

I'd bet it is magnetic. The red flags are fluttering like a Soviet May Day parade on Red Square.

 

The tail feathers on the eagle don't show up at all.

 

Chinese counterfeit.
And many counterfeits are not magnetic. Being magnetic can condemn a coin (excluding 1943 cents and various foreign coins), but not being magnetic is no indication of authenticity.

 

Seated Liberty Halves are my most favorite series. This example of a 1852-O sends up the red flag, as others have said in earlier posts, look at the font of the numerals in the date, as well as the overall finish/toning that lead to the conclusion of a counterfeit coin. These characteristics also manifest themselves in the fake Chinese Morgans. The credentials of the seller are questionable at best as well. Otherwise not a bad fake and may fool the inexperienced individual.

 

The one thing that strikes me about this coin is that the mint mark doesn't look right. It's skewed slightly, at least to me. I don't know a lot about the Seated series, but to me the MM just looks out of whack in relation to the lettering below and the branch above it. The bottom of the O should be in line with the serif on the F of HALF as in the real one posted by @lordmarcovan. It isn't. It points to the top line of the F.

 

The only thing they left out was "Made in China." Thanks for posting it.

 

Not even one! This has to be the most glaring missing feature. Good call.

 

I've recently seen coins for sale with that exact same background and questioned the coins in view. Maybe a fake seller that collects money and you never see a coin and their profiles disappear from eBay?

 

the usual trash with many problems, but I could see how some folks would be fooled at arm's length.

 

I believe it's the new version approved by the CCP. The eagle had its tail feathers shot off by a super accurate Chinese AA missile as it flew over the Spratley Islands in the South China Sea. Take that, Capitalist Scavenger Fowl!
sorry, I digress. should not have had that second glass of wine.