Coinage Math Challenge

Discussion in 'Contests' started by Ed Sims, Jun 1, 2014.

  1. bdunnse

    bdunnse Who dat?

    Not sure what this contest is about. Seems you have to guess at what the rules will be. Everyone's answer seems to be right so far until he sees your answer then makes up a rule that invalidates it. Am I missing something (I assume I am)?
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. Ed Sims

    Ed Sims Well-Known Member

    Everyone can submit a different guess each day, so go for it!:happy:
    If you read the original post the very first paragraph states specifically what the contest is about. You have to guess the number of coins, their denomination and type that add up to the amount of $30.67.

    A list of the denominations and their types which were selected from is provided and so forth.

    One guess per day per member.

    What you are missing is that each guess thus far does not have the correct combination of denominations, types for each denomination and the quantity for each which must add up to a specified total.

    For example the sum of the coins is $100.00. In that hundred dollars is a quantity of coins, 185 which you do not know. What you have to do is guess what those coins actually are and how many of each. In this example you have to try and determine that there is a total of 20 one cent pieces of which there are 5 draped bust, 10 Indian head and 5 Lincoln cents. Repeat for the two cent pieces, three cent pieces, five cent pieces, dimes, 20 cent pieces, et cetera. The trick is that not all denominations from half cent through double eagle are included in the total amount nor are all of the various types for each denomination.

    The first person to correctly guess the actual combination of coins wins the contest.
     
    wcoins and bdunnse like this.
  4. bdunnse

    bdunnse Who dat?

    I read the first post clearly and several times looking for more rules than just "guess". I just don't understand the challenge of a guessing game with no criteria (other than what you learn from the incorrect guesses). So I'm just going to wait until all but one of the possible answers have been guessed then submit the winning combo! :p
     
  5. wcoins

    wcoins GEM-ber

    1 x Eagle Liberty -10.00
    ------------------------------------------
    2 x Gold Dollars - Liberty Heads - 2.00
    -------------------------------------------
    4 x Quarter Eagles - 2 Liberty, 2 Indian - 10.00
    ----------------------------------------------------------
    3 x Peace dollars - 3.00
    1 x Trade Dollar - 1.00
    -------------------------------------------
    5 x Walking Liberty half dollars -2.50
    1 x Franklin half dollar -0.50
    -------------------------------------------
    1 x Jefferson nickel - 0.05
    3 x Buffalo nickel - 0.15
    2 x Liberty nickel - 0.10
    2 x Shield nickel -0.10
    ------------------------------------------
    4 x Mercury dimes -0.40
    1 x Barber dime -0.10
    3 x Roosevelt dimes - 0.30
    2 x Seated Liberty dimes - 0.20
    -----------------------------------------
    4 x 2 cent piece- 0.08
    ----------------------------------------
    4 x Coronet cent - 0.04
    8 x Lincoln wheat - 0.08
    7 x Indian Head - 0.07
    ----------------------------------------
    58 coins
     
  6. Ed Sims

    Ed Sims Well-Known Member

    There are no "rules" per se, just the information necessary to determine the correct combination.

    It is not a simple guessing game as you think it is. It is as more of a math and logic quiz that needs to be solved.

    If you wait until there is just one possible answer you would have waited too long because it won't get to one possible answer left.
     
    wcoins and bdunnse like this.
  7. jay4202472000

    jay4202472000 Well-Known Member

    Half Cents

    10 Capped Bust Half Cents

    Cents

    4 Classic Head Lg Cents
    4 Indian Head Cents
    5 Lincoln Cents

    2 Cents

    1 Two Cent

    3 Cents

    4 Nickel Three Cents

    5 Cents

    8 Seated Liberty Half Dimes
    5 Buffalo Nickels
    1 Jefferson Nickel

    10 Cents

    6 Seated Liberty Dimes
    1 Barber Dime
    4 Mercury Dimes

    20 Cents

    4 Twenty Cents

    25 Cents

    4 Seated Liberty Quarters
    3 Standing Liberty Quarters
    4 Washington Quarters

    50 Cents

    3 Seated Liberty Half Dollars
    2 Walking Liberty Half Dollars
    1 Franklin Half Dollar

    Silver $1

    3 Seated Liberty Dollars
    2 Morgan Dollars
    3 Peace Dollars

    Gold $1

    4 Indian Princess Gold Dollars

    Gold $10

    1 Capped Bust Gold Eagle

    87 Total Coins = $ 30.67
     
    Ed Sims likes this.
  8. Ed Sims

    Ed Sims Well-Known Member

    From the members who submitted guesses on 6-4 and 6-5 here are the following results for each.

    wcoins's correct guesses: Gold dollars (3), all of the correct denominations with no extras not included.

    chip's correct guesses: Bust half dollars (2)

    ace71499's correct guesses: Liberty head quarter eagle (1), Capped Bust eagle (1)

    Jay 420247000's correct guesses: nothing this but keep trying.

    To all, submit different combinations each day.

    Now that all of the correct denominations have been identified determining the correct types for each the their quantities is what needs to be accomplished next.

    Keep in mind in some cases there are more types for a denomination whose actual quantities have been determined.

    Today's clue, there are more than 80 but less than 120 coins required, it is an even number, and more than 70% of that total are coins whose denomination is less than 50 cents.

    Good Luck!
     
    wcoins likes this.
  9. wcoins

    wcoins GEM-ber

    1 x Eagle (Capped Bust) - 10.00
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    3 x Gold Dollars - 3 x Princess - 3.00
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------
    1 x Quarter Eagle - Liberty Head - 2.50
    2 x Quarter Eagle - Capped Bust - 5.00
    ----------------------------------------------------------
    3 x Peace dollars - 3.00
    -------------------------------------------
    2 x Bust Half Dollar - 1.00
    3 x Barber half dollars -1.50
    1 x Franklin half dollar -0.50
    -------------------------------------------
    1 x Jefferson nickel - 0.05
    8 x Buffalo nickel - 0.40
    6 x Liberty nickel - 0.30
    4 x Shield nickel -0.20
    ------------------------------------------
    4 x Mercury dimes -0.40
    1 x Barber dime -0.10
    15 x Roosevelt dimes - 1.50
    4 x Bust dimes - 0.40
    3 x Seated Liberty dimes - 0.30
    -----------------------------------------
    6 x 2 cent piece - 0.12
    ----------------------------------------
    6 x Coronet cent - 0.06
    19 x Lincoln wheat - 0.19
    15 x Indian Head - 0.15
    ---------------------------------------
    108 coins
     
    Ed Sims likes this.
  10. jay4202472000

    jay4202472000 Well-Known Member

    Cents
    10 Classic Head Lg Cents
    10 Indian Head Cents
    11 Lincoln Cents

    2 Cents
    8 Two Cents

    5 Cents
    6 Seated Liberty Half Dimes

    5 Shield Nickels
    8 Buffalo Nickels
    1 Jefferson Nickel

    10 Cents
    4 Bust Dimes
    8 Seated Liberty Dimes
    1 Barber Dime
    4 Mercury Dimes

    50 Cents
    2 Ca
    pped Bust Half Dollars
    3 Barber Half Dollars
    1 Franklin Half Dollar

    Silver $1
    2 Seated Liberty Dollars
    4 Trade Dollars
    3 Peace Dollars

    Gold $1
    3 Indian Princess Gold Dollars

    Gold $2.50
    1 Liberty Head Gold Quarter Eagle

    Gold $10
    1 Capped Bust Gold Eagle

    96 Total Coins = $ 30.67
     
    Ed Sims likes this.
  11. Ed Sims

    Ed Sims Well-Known Member

    Very good Jay. You're getting the hang of it. Got some right this time though right now I can't say which.
     
    wcoins likes this.
  12. ace71499

    ace71499 Young Numismatic

    Sorry Wcoins. Its easier to just edit jay's with the bolded non bolded. Thanks Jay for letting me copy :) (don't worry I compiled my list before I copied yours)
    Half Cents
    8 Classic Head Lg Cents
    Cents
    20 Indian Head Cents
    20 Lincoln Cents

    2 Cents
    5 Two Cents
    3Cents
    1 Nickel

    5 Cents

    9 Shield Nickels
    10 Buffalo Nickels
    1 Jefferson Nickel

    10 Cents
    2 Bust Dimes
    9Seated Liberty Dimes
    1 Barber Dime
    4 Mercury Dimes

    50 Cents
    2 Ca
    pped Bust Half Dollars
    3 Barber Half Dollars
    1 Franklin Half Dollar

    Silver $1
    4 Seated Liberty Dollars
    2 Trade Dollars
    3 Peace Dollars

    Gold $1
    3 Indian Princess Gold Dollars

    Gold $2.50
    1 Liberty Head Gold Quarter Eagle

    Gold $10
    1 Capped Bust Gold Eagle
    110 coins
     
  13. Ed Sims

    Ed Sims Well-Known Member

    Latest recap of the most recent guess submissions.

    wcoins's correct guesses:
    Bust half dollar (2)

    Jay420247000's correct guesses:
    2 cent pieces (8)
    5 cent pieces - Shield nickels (5)
    Half dollars - Bust (2)
    Silver dollars - Seated Liberty (2) which is the second of the two types for the silver dollars
    Gold dollars - IndianPrincess head (3)

    ace71499's correct guesses:
    Half dollars - Bust (2)
    Gold dollars - Indian Princess head (3)

    Based on the guesses made on 6-1, 6-4, 6-8, and 6-9 this is where it stands as of now:



    0 - Half cents

    ?
    - Cents: Draped Bust large cent, Classic Head large cent, Liberty Head large cent, Indian head cent, Lincoln cent

    8 - Two cents = $0.16

    0 - Three cents


    ? - Five cents: Bust half dime, Seated Liberty half dime, Shield nickel (5) = $0.25,
    Liberty nickel, Buffalo nickel, Jefferson nickel (1) = $0.05

    ? - Dimes: Bust, Seated Liberty, Barber (1) = $0.10, Mercury (4) = $0.40, Roosevelt

    0 - Twenty cents

    0 - Quarters

    6 - Half dollars: Bust (2)
    , Seated Liberty (3), Franklin (1) = $3.00

    5 - Silver Dollars: Seated Liberty (2), Peace (3) = $5.00

    3 - Gold dollars: Indian Princess Head (3) = $3.00


    ? - Quarter Eagles: Capped Bust, Classic head, Liberty head (1) = $2.50, Indian

    0 - Half Eagles

    1
    - Eagle: Capped Bust = $10.00

    0 - Double Eagles

    Clue for the day: Three coin types have quantities with double digits.
     
    wcoins likes this.
  14. jay4202472000

    jay4202472000 Well-Known Member

    Cents
    16 Draped Bust LG Cents
    12 Indian Head Cents
    13 Lincoln Cents

    2 Cents
    8 Two Cents

    5 Cents

    4 Bust Half Dimes
    5 Shield Nickels
    4 Buffalo Nickels
    1 Jefferson Nickel

    10 Cents
    4 Roosevelt Dimes
    1 Barber Dime
    4 Mercury Dimes

    50 Cents
    2 Capped Bust Half Dollars

    3 Seated Liberty Half Dollars
    1 Franklin Half Dollar

    Silver $1
    2 Seated Liberty Dollars
    3 Peace Dollars


    Gold $1
    3 Indian Princess Gold Dollars

    Gold $2.50
    1 Liberty Head Gold Quarter Eagle
    2
    Classic Head Gold Quarter Eagles

    Gold $10
    1 Capped Bust Gold Eagle

    90 Total Coins = $ 30.67
     
    Ed Sims likes this.
  15. wcoins

    wcoins GEM-ber

    1 - Eagle: Capped Bust = $10.00
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    3 - Quarter Eagles:
    -Classic head (2) - 5.00
    -Liberty head (1) = 2.50
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    3 - Gold dollars: Indian Princess Head (3) = $3.00
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    5 - Silver Dollars: Seated Liberty (2), Peace (3) = $5.00
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    6 - Half dollars: Bust (2), Seated Liberty (3), Franklin (1) = $3.00
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    11 - Dimes:
    -Seated Liberty (4) - 0.40
    -Barber (1) = $0.10,
    -Mercury (4) = $0.40,
    -Roosevelt - (2) - 0.20
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    11 - Five cents:
    -Shield nickel (5) = $0.25,
    -Liberty nickel (3) - 0.15
    -Buffalo nickel (2) - 0.10
    -Jefferson nickel (1) = $0.05
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    8 - Two cents = $0.16
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    36 - Cents:
    -Liberty Head large cent (11) - 0.11
    -Indian head cent (12) - 0.12
    -Lincoln cent (13) - 0.13
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    84 coins



     
    Ed Sims and jay4202472000 like this.
  16. jay4202472000

    jay4202472000 Well-Known Member

    Cents
    14 Draped Bust LG Cents
    14 Indian Head Cents
    13 Lincoln Cents

    2 Cents
    8 Two Cents

    5 Cents

    3 Seated Liberty Half Dimes
    5 Shield Nickels
    6 Buffalo Nickels
    1 Jefferson Nickel
    3 Liberty Head Nickels

    10 Cents
    2 Roosevelt Dimes
    1 Barber Dime
    4 Mercury Dimes

    50 Cents
    2 Capped Bust Half Dollars

    3 Seated Liberty Half Dollars
    1 Franklin Half Dollar

    Silver $1
    2 Seated Liberty Dollars
    3 Peace Dollars


    Gold $1
    3 Indian Princess Gold Dollars

    Gold $2.50
    1 Liberty Head Gold Quarter Eagle
    2 Indian Gold Quarter Eagles

    Gold $10
    1 Capped Bust Gold Eagle

    92 Total Coins = $ 30.67
     
    wcoins and Ed Sims like this.
  17. jay4202472000

    jay4202472000 Well-Known Member

    Cents
    21 Liberty Head LG Cents
    22 Indian Head Cents
    13 Lincoln Cents

    2 Cents
    8 Two Cents

    5 Cents

    3 Seated Liberty Half Dimes
    5 Shield Nickels
    2 Buffalo Nickels
    1 Jefferson Nickel
    3 Liberty Head Nickels

    10 Cents
    4 Seated Liberty Dimes
    1 Barber Dime
    4 Mercury Dimes

    50 Cents
    2 Capped Bust Half Dollars

    3 Seated Liberty Half Dollars
    1 Franklin Half Dollar

    Silver $1
    2 Seated Liberty Dollars
    3 Peace Dollars


    Gold $1
    3 Indian Princess Gold Dollars

    Gold $2.50
    1 Liberty Head Gold Quarter Eagle
    2 Indian Gold Quarter Eagles

    Gold $10
    1 Capped Bust Gold Eagle

    102 Total Coins = $ 30.67
     
    wcoins and Ed Sims like this.
  18. chip

    chip Novice collector

    0half cents, 231 cents, 56 indian heads, 175 lincolns, 8 2 centers, 22 five centers, 2 capped busties, 3 seated liberty, 5 shield nickels, 11 buffalos, and one Jeffy, 11 ten centers, 6 seated liberty 1 babrber, and 4 mercs, 6 fitty centers, 2 capped busties, 3 seated liberty, and one franklin, 5 silver dollars, 2 seated liberty and 3 peace, 3 gold princess head dollars, 2 quarter eagles, one classic head and one liberty head, and one capped bust eagle
     
    wcoins and Ed Sims like this.
  19. wcoins

    wcoins GEM-ber

    1 - Eagle: Capped Bust = $10.00
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    3 - Quarter Eagles:
    -Indian (2) - 5.00
    -Liberty head (1) = 2.50

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    3 - Gold dollars: Indian Princess Head (3) = $3.00
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    5 - Silver Dollars: Seated Liberty (2), Peace (3) = $5.00
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    6 - Half dollars: Bust (2), Seated Liberty (3), Franklin (1) = $3.00
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    11 - Dimes:
    -Barber (1) = $0.10,
    -Mercury (4) = $0.40
    -
    Seated Liberty (6) - 0.60
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    9 - Five cents:
    -Shield nickel (5) = $0.25,
    -Jefferson nickel (1) = $0.05

    -Seated Liberty half dime (3) - 0.15

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    8 - Two cents = $0.16
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    46 - Cents:
    -Liberty Head large cent (12) - 0.12
    -Indian head cent (21) - 0.21
    -Lincoln cent (13) - 0.13
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    92 coins
     
    jay4202472000 likes this.
  20. Ed Sims

    Ed Sims Well-Known Member

    Clue of the day, all of the correct types per denomination have been identified in the recap below. Now you just have to figure out how many of each. The total number of coins is an even number.

    This will be the last recap. The first person to match the correct number of coins to each denomination/type will win the prize.

    Cents: (?) = (?)
    Draped Bust large cent (?),
    Liberty head large cent (?),
    Indian head cent (?),
    Lincoln cent (13) = $0.13

    Two cents (8) = $0.16

    Five cents: (?) = (?)
    Seated Liberty half dime (3) = $0.15,
    Shield nickel (5) = $0.25,
    Buffalo nickel (?),
    Jefferson nickel (1) = $0.05

    Dimes: (?) = (?)
    Bust (?),
    Barber (1) = $0.10,
    Mercury (4) = $0.40,

    Half dollars: (6) = $3.00
    Bust (2) = $1.00,
    Barber (3) = $1.50,
    Franklin (1) = $0.50

    Silver Dollars: (5) = $5.00
    Seated Liberty (2) = $2.00,
    Peace (3) = $3.00

    Gold dollars: (3) = $3.00

    Indian Princess Head = $3.00

    Quarter Eagles: (3) = $7.50
    Liberty head (1) = $2.50,
    Indian (3) = $5.00

    Eagles: (1) Capped Bust = $10.00


    (?) Coins = $30.67
     
    wcoins likes this.
  21. twopillow

    twopillow The Dude Abides

    Here's my guess...

    Cents: (31) = $0.31

    Draped Bust large cent (1) = $0.01
    Liberty head large cent (2) = $0.02
    Indian head cent (15) = $0.15
    Lincoln cent (13) = $0.13

    Two cents (8) = $0.16
    Five cents: (20) = $1.00
    Seated Liberty half dime (3) = $0.15
    Shield nickel (5) = $0.25
    Buffalo nickel (11) = $0.55
    Jefferson nickel (1) = $0.05

    Dimes: (7) = $0.70
    Bust (2) = $0.20
    Barber (1) = $0.10
    Mercury (4) = $0.40

    Half dollars: (6) = $3.00
    Bust (2) = $1.00
    Barber (3) = $1.50
    Franklin (1) = $0.50

    Silver Dollars: (5) = $5.00
    Seated Liberty (2) = $2.00
    Peace (3) = $3.00

    Gold dollars: (3) = $3.00

    Indian Princess Head = $3.00

    Quarter Eagles: (3) = $7.50
    Liberty head (1) = $2.50
    Indian (3) = $5.00

    Eagles: (1) Capped Bust = $10.00


    84 Coins = $30.67
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page