Log in or Sign up
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
World Coins
>
Canada
>
Reply to Thread
Message:
<p>[QUOTE="Bill in Burl, post: 3012004, member: 23692"]Yartiques ... to kinda answer your question about your 2 1859's that look different. The 1859's are all bronze (or were supposed to be). We did a study in 2012 and published it in the Canadian Numismatic Journal (March issue) on the "brass" 1859's to see if we could nail down what ensued to have brass cents. There are less than about 10 known and we found that they most probably were the result of improper mixing of the alloy in the pot when making the ingots. The ingots were then rolled into sheets and planchets cut from them.</p><p><br /></p><p>The bronze for the 59's, that came from Heaton but were minted by the RCM, was supposed to be 95 CU, 4 SN and 1 ZN. To really be called "brass" it should be 67-85 CU with a much higher Zinc than tin in the remainder to make 100. So we wanted to take a large, random, sample of coins to see what we found. </p><p><br /></p><p>I had a hoarde of nearly 1000 1859's, so we XRF'd about 500 or so for the study to see what we got for what the range of alloy %'s. We tried to throw more coins into the mix that looked "yellowish", one of the visual clues as to brass vs bronze. We found aloys from 90.96 Cu, .32 Zn, 2.87 Sn and no lead(Pb).... to 95.98 Cu, 1.85 Zn, 6.29 Sn & .76 Pb. Those %'s marked the highest concentrations of each alloy element and, similarly, the lowest. We had some that were vaguely close to brass, but none that could be considered so. For you mathematics fans out there, you can see that no single coin had either of the above percentages .. they were just the high and low % of each metal that we found. </p><p><br /></p><p>It was our unanimous conclusion that the brass cents out there (or claim to be) were the result of improper mixing of the alloy metals in the crucible/vat that was then poured into the small brick molds. Just like pouring water out of a glass, either the top water in the glass actually comes out last (surface tension) or the heaviest stuff comes out last. Only a portion of the metal alloy in the brick would need to be lower in Cu and higher in Zn ... to have it come out in specific areas on the rolled sheet from which the planchets were cut. </p><p><br /></p><p>Very few of the known "brass" cents have been XRF'd or lab-tested to see what the actual alloys were. Those that have tend to support our hypothesis. For years, "brass" cents were determined by the Grading Companies by scratching the edge of the coin with a diamond or glass and then looked at the scratch in the sunlight (Not under incandescent light) to see if it looked "yellow"... a far from scientific test. There are any number of household cleaning agents found under your sink that can turn a bronze 1859 into a yellow-looking coin. That is just caused by the chemical reaction with the highly-reactive copper in the coin. If you, Yartiques, have 2 1859's that look different, I can most heartedly suggest that they are bronze, not brass, and that one of them got too close to a cleaning agent.[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>
[QUOTE="Bill in Burl, post: 3012004, member: 23692"]Yartiques ... to kinda answer your question about your 2 1859's that look different. The 1859's are all bronze (or were supposed to be). We did a study in 2012 and published it in the Canadian Numismatic Journal (March issue) on the "brass" 1859's to see if we could nail down what ensued to have brass cents. There are less than about 10 known and we found that they most probably were the result of improper mixing of the alloy in the pot when making the ingots. The ingots were then rolled into sheets and planchets cut from them. The bronze for the 59's, that came from Heaton but were minted by the RCM, was supposed to be 95 CU, 4 SN and 1 ZN. To really be called "brass" it should be 67-85 CU with a much higher Zinc than tin in the remainder to make 100. So we wanted to take a large, random, sample of coins to see what we found. I had a hoarde of nearly 1000 1859's, so we XRF'd about 500 or so for the study to see what we got for what the range of alloy %'s. We tried to throw more coins into the mix that looked "yellowish", one of the visual clues as to brass vs bronze. We found aloys from 90.96 Cu, .32 Zn, 2.87 Sn and no lead(Pb).... to 95.98 Cu, 1.85 Zn, 6.29 Sn & .76 Pb. Those %'s marked the highest concentrations of each alloy element and, similarly, the lowest. We had some that were vaguely close to brass, but none that could be considered so. For you mathematics fans out there, you can see that no single coin had either of the above percentages .. they were just the high and low % of each metal that we found. It was our unanimous conclusion that the brass cents out there (or claim to be) were the result of improper mixing of the alloy metals in the crucible/vat that was then poured into the small brick molds. Just like pouring water out of a glass, either the top water in the glass actually comes out last (surface tension) or the heaviest stuff comes out last. Only a portion of the metal alloy in the brick would need to be lower in Cu and higher in Zn ... to have it come out in specific areas on the rolled sheet from which the planchets were cut. Very few of the known "brass" cents have been XRF'd or lab-tested to see what the actual alloys were. Those that have tend to support our hypothesis. For years, "brass" cents were determined by the Grading Companies by scratching the edge of the coin with a diamond or glass and then looked at the scratch in the sunlight (Not under incandescent light) to see if it looked "yellow"... a far from scientific test. There are any number of household cleaning agents found under your sink that can turn a bronze 1859 into a yellow-looking coin. That is just caused by the chemical reaction with the highly-reactive copper in the coin. If you, Yartiques, have 2 1859's that look different, I can most heartedly suggest that they are bronze, not brass, and that one of them got too close to a cleaning agent.[/QUOTE]
Your name or email address:
Do you already have an account?
No, create an account now.
Yes, my password is:
Forgot your password?
Stay logged in
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
World Coins
>
Canada
>
Home
Home
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Forums
Forums
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Posts
Competitions
Competitions
Quick Links
Competition Index
Rules, Terms & Conditions
Gallery
Gallery
Quick Links
Search Media
New Media
Showcase
Showcase
Quick Links
Search Items
Most Active Members
New Items
Directory
Directory
Quick Links
Directory Home
New Listings
Members
Members
Quick Links
Notable Members
Current Visitors
Recent Activity
New Profile Posts
Sponsors
Menu
Search
Search titles only
Posted by Member:
Separate names with a comma.
Newer Than:
Search this thread only
Search this forum only
Display results as threads
Useful Searches
Recent Posts
More...