Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="Kryptonitecomic, post: 1011310, member: 26784"]I think the TPGs clearly got the first two right....I had no concerns about them being NT from your im ages...the 1898-O looks clearly AT to me but it's not an AT screamer so I can see how some might argue NT. As far as the priced paid....this is something I clearly know a lot about as both a buyer and seller of toned coins for more than 5 years. The 1889 looks to be about a $200 dollar coin based on the double sided toning but $250 is still a reasonable price and I could see other collectors stepping up to pay that. The 1883-O I would value at at least $125 due to the rainbow toning on the money side of the coin....you paid the right price for that coin...good job. The 1898-O...even if it was NT would only be worth about $80 bucks tops....not enough color or eye appeal be worth anywhere near what you paid and being that it's raw...that would drop the buy price even lower.[/QUOTE]