Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="CamaroDMD, post: 2591620, member: 5233"]So, I tried it.  When I opened the set, I made sure that there was no way I could tell which was which based on markings (as all the coins are sitting in their original box with the obverse visible). As I looked at the set...this is how it was organized from left to right: UNC, UNC, Reverse Proof, Proof, UNC.  First, I looked at the two UNC coins on the left...being side by side I thought it would be good to compare them.  Looking at them side by side, I noticed an obvious difference in the finish.  The coin to the far left looked a little more "brilliant" than the coin to its right.  I figured one of these was the burnished and the other was a normal UNC.  I thought about it for a moment (not knowing which was which at first glance).  After some thought, I assumed the coin with the more polished planchet would...if anything...have a more brilliant finish.  So, I decided that that coin must be the burnished coin.  I flipped both of them over and the coin on the far left (with the more brilliant finish) had a W mint mark...so I was correct. Although side by side it was obvious that the coins were different, at least to me it's not a huge difference in finish.  Not being a huge expert in this set, I think I would personally have a difficult time telling the coins apart if they were not side by side.[/QUOTE]