Log in or Sign up
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Ancient Coins
>
Are overstrikes considered mint errors ?
>
Reply to Thread
Message:
<p>[QUOTE="-monolith-, post: 25471713, member: 150064"]Regarding ancient coins, do you consider an overstrike to be a mint error? My belief is no, since the coins were "restruck" for a reason. Here are a few of my overstrikes:</p><p><br /></p><p>[ATTACH=full]1630360[/ATTACH] </p><p><b>Province, City - Reign: </b>Macedonia, Kingdom of - Kassander</p><p><b>Denomination: </b>AE Half unit</p><p><b>Mint: </b>Uncertain Mint – Western Asia Minor (316 - 297 BC)</p><p><b>Obverse: </b>Helmeted head of Athena right (overstruck on reverse of Macedonian shield type)</p><p><b>Reverse</b>: <b>(BAΣΙΛ)ΕΩ(Σ) - K(AΣΣ)ANΔPO(Y), </b>Club above; bow-in-bowcase below (overstruck on obverse of Macedonian shield type)</p><p><b>References: </b>SNG Cop 1159; Moushmov 7271; Valassiadis, Contribution 8; HGC 3, 997</p><p>[ATTACH=full]1630361[/ATTACH]</p><p><b>Province, City: </b>Mysia, Kyzikos (Cyzicus)</p><p><b>Mint: </b>Kyzikos (5th - 4th centuries BC, sometime between 410 – 394 BC during the Peloponnesian War) – symmachy coinage </p><p><b>Obverse: </b>Prow to right; overstruck on Kore Soteira head right, wearing saccos</p><p><b>Reverse</b>: <b>K-Y / Σ-I </b>on either side of bucranium, all within oak wreath; overstruck on bull left, butting with <b>K-Y / Σ-I</b> above and monogram below</p><p><b>References: overstruck coin reference </b>- SNG France 5, 438; SNG von Aulock 1231; Von Fritze-III 11</p><p><b>base coin reference</b> - SNG France 5, 436-437; SNG von Aulock 1230; Von Fritze-III 10</p><p>[ATTACH=full]1630362[/ATTACH]</p><p><b>Province, City: </b>Mysia, Kyzikos (Cyzicus) - civic issue</p><p><b>Mint: </b>Kyzikos (300 - 200 BC)</p><p><b>Obverse: </b>Tunny fish left in corn wreath attached to sheaf of grain overstruck on head of Kore right, wreathed with corn.</p><p><b>Reverse:</b> <b>K-Y / Z-I</b> to left and right of wreath; <b>AΓ</b> monogram within oak-wreath, <b>Δ</b> below overstruck on tripod, radiate disk above, tunny fish below.</p><p><b>References: </b>BMCG 16. 38. 145 (restruck); Imhoof MG (Mobbaies grecques) 214. 83 (restruck); Mysia, Kyzikos - Von Fritze, Nomisma X, Kyzikos, Gruppe II, 14</p><p>[ATTACH=full]1630368[/ATTACH]</p><p><b>Province, City: </b>Mysia, Lampsakos</p><p><b>Mint: </b>Lampsakos (2nd-1st Century BC)</p><p><b>Obverse: </b>Laureate head of Apollo to right overstruck on head of Athena to right wearing crested Corinthan helmet</p><p><b>Reverse: ΛΑΜ</b>, Kithara (Lyre); in field to left forepart of Pegasos to left overstruck </p><p>reverse - undertype rotated 90 degrees (pegasos legs at bottom of lyre and it's head is at the <b>ΛΑΜ</b>)</p><p><b>References:</b> Plankenhorn, Mysien, p. 96, 40; SNG France 1234; SNG Tübingen 2307[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>
[QUOTE="-monolith-, post: 25471713, member: 150064"]Regarding ancient coins, do you consider an overstrike to be a mint error? My belief is no, since the coins were "restruck" for a reason. Here are a few of my overstrikes: [ATTACH=full]1630360[/ATTACH] [B]Province, City - Reign: [/B]Macedonia, Kingdom of - Kassander [B]Denomination: [/B]AE Half unit [B]Mint: [/B]Uncertain Mint – Western Asia Minor (316 - 297 BC) [B]Obverse: [/B]Helmeted head of Athena right (overstruck on reverse of Macedonian shield type) [B]Reverse[/B]: [B](BAΣΙΛ)ΕΩ(Σ) - K(AΣΣ)ANΔPO(Y), [/B]Club above; bow-in-bowcase below (overstruck on obverse of Macedonian shield type) [B]References: [/B]SNG Cop 1159; Moushmov 7271; Valassiadis, Contribution 8; HGC 3, 997 [ATTACH=full]1630361[/ATTACH] [B]Province, City: [/B]Mysia, Kyzikos (Cyzicus) [B]Mint: [/B]Kyzikos (5th - 4th centuries BC, sometime between 410 – 394 BC during the Peloponnesian War) – symmachy coinage [B]Obverse: [/B]Prow to right; overstruck on Kore Soteira head right, wearing saccos [B]Reverse[/B]: [B]K-Y / Σ-I [/B]on either side of bucranium, all within oak wreath; overstruck on bull left, butting with [B]K-Y / Σ-I[/B] above and monogram below [B]References: overstruck coin reference [/B]- SNG France 5, 438; SNG von Aulock 1231; Von Fritze-III 11 [B]base coin reference[/B] - SNG France 5, 436-437; SNG von Aulock 1230; Von Fritze-III 10 [ATTACH=full]1630362[/ATTACH] [B]Province, City: [/B]Mysia, Kyzikos (Cyzicus) - civic issue [B]Mint: [/B]Kyzikos (300 - 200 BC) [B]Obverse: [/B]Tunny fish left in corn wreath attached to sheaf of grain overstruck on head of Kore right, wreathed with corn. [B]Reverse:[/B] [B]K-Y / Z-I[/B] to left and right of wreath; [B]AΓ[/B] monogram within oak-wreath, [B]Δ[/B] below overstruck on tripod, radiate disk above, tunny fish below. [B]References: [/B]BMCG 16. 38. 145 (restruck); Imhoof MG (Mobbaies grecques) 214. 83 (restruck); Mysia, Kyzikos - Von Fritze, Nomisma X, Kyzikos, Gruppe II, 14 [ATTACH=full]1630368[/ATTACH] [B]Province, City: [/B]Mysia, Lampsakos [B]Mint: [/B]Lampsakos (2nd-1st Century BC) [B]Obverse: [/B]Laureate head of Apollo to right overstruck on head of Athena to right wearing crested Corinthan helmet [B]Reverse: ΛΑΜ[/B], Kithara (Lyre); in field to left forepart of Pegasos to left overstruck reverse - undertype rotated 90 degrees (pegasos legs at bottom of lyre and it's head is at the [B]ΛΑΜ[/B]) [B]References:[/B] Plankenhorn, Mysien, p. 96, 40; SNG France 1234; SNG Tübingen 2307[/QUOTE]
Your name or email address:
Do you already have an account?
No, create an account now.
Yes, my password is:
Forgot your password?
Stay logged in
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Ancient Coins
>
Are overstrikes considered mint errors ?
>
Home
Home
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Forums
Forums
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Posts
Competitions
Competitions
Quick Links
Competition Index
Rules, Terms & Conditions
Gallery
Gallery
Quick Links
Search Media
New Media
Showcase
Showcase
Quick Links
Search Items
Most Active Members
New Items
Directory
Directory
Quick Links
Directory Home
New Listings
Members
Members
Quick Links
Notable Members
Current Visitors
Recent Activity
New Profile Posts
Sponsors
Menu
Search
Search titles only
Posted by Member:
Separate names with a comma.
Newer Than:
Search this thread only
Search this forum only
Display results as threads
Useful Searches
Recent Posts
More...