Another Morgan Dollar GTG: PNNA Show pick ups.

Here are a couple Morgan Dollars I picked up at the PNNA show yesterday. I thought I would do a guess the grade on them and see what you all thought of them. Any comments are alway's appreciated.

A full show report will be coming after the reveal.

First up an 1880-S Morgan Dollar


And an 1885-O Morgan Dollar

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

1-64+PL
2-65 Nicely struck minimal marks toning may have held it back a point.
Hey what do I know

 

MS64PL - maybe 65 if all that fuss on the cheek is just frost breaks.
MS66 - I agree with dwhiz but I'll guess it didn't get held back.

Very nice picks and pics

 

MS63PL
MS65, purty

 

I'm gonna go with

64PL
64 in an old fatty under graded by at least a point

Love that 85-O

 

MS-64PL, possibly DMPL.

MS-65

 

MS64PL as said wouldn't be surprised at a 65PL.
MS65

 

My thoughts exactly. I will add that i think they are nice coins. That cheek on the 85O looks very nice, and the chatter in the fields is sort of hidden by the toning

 

MS 64 PL
MS 65 (small white Anacs holder is my guess on this one)

 

Some good guesses so far. But nobody has nailed them both. I'm curious as to what @physics-fan3.14 thinks of them.

 

First one I'm guessing 63PL.

Since 65 is an incorrect guess for the second, I'm going to guess it was strictly graded at a 64.

 

Since my original guesses weren't correct, I'll say 65PL or DMPL for the first one, and 66 for the second one. IMO, a bit high, but I'm just guessing the TPG grade.

 

LOL, I probably should not have said anything, but I didn't say they were easy either.

 

I'd like to buy a vowel please, no wait I'm going to use my phone-a-friend...

 

My guess on the first one is MS63PL
and MS65 on the second one, solely because I have very similar looking 1885-O that has that same grade.

 

Did the first coin miss PL? Nice scoop if that's the case

 

63 PL
64

 

MS-63 DMPL
MS-64

 

63
65+

 

MS65 DMPL
MS66

The disruptions on the cheek of the 1880-S look like luster grazes to me, not bag marks. The only thing that might hold back the 1885-O is the luster. It doesn't look booming but you are so good at photographing your coins with their best possible face that I have to conclude it is premium gem.