Log in or Sign up
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Coin Chat
>
40% silver.
>
Reply to Thread
Message:
<p>[QUOTE="Kasia, post: 3267845, member: 31533"]As with many things, there were a number of factors going into this. The Franklin half was not that old, having only started in 1948 and so should still have had a number of years into it before the design was changed. If it had continued, I think that even with silver producing states opposition, that the half would have also gone with the no silver in 1965 and we would not have this discussion. Just like the Washington Quarter or the Roosevelt Dime, a change to silver would not have caused any problem. Silver older halves would have continued to be pulled because of the change, but minting more halves would have let it be ok. However, JFK was assasinated in late Nov, 1963, and there was a rush job to put him on coinage. So much so, and also the fact that Franklin was not the most popular real person on coins at that time and he had never been a president, compelled the halves to be the one to be changed. First mintings of JFK halves came in January 1964. That is fast, to have less than two months from someone dying to having his image on a major US coin. </p><p><br /></p><p>Also, there was not any public notice (forewarning around 1963, early 1964 to the general populace) that coins would lose the silver in 1965. Couple that with the reasoning that the Kennedy coins were also being hoarded rather than having general usage and the mint not wanting to make the 1964 coins a one-off silver issue (with no silver in any future ones) which could make the entire 1964 minting a waste of their time and effort. They still probably(my speculation) thought they could get past the hoarding of the first year issue and that halves would continue to circulate freely. But, in 1965-1972, these were the first years where that would not happen. And I don't think it was simply because of the Franklin half being changed. These were years that because the mint also removed mintmarks to discourage collecting and years where the larger bills and larger coins were less in favor for general usage. Fifty cents was no longer a big deal to people and it was much easier to simply use quarters instead of halves. It became a rarity to even contemplate seeing a 500 or 1000 dollar bill also. The last 1000 dollar bill had been printed in 1945 and so just over time it would have caused those not to be much in 'circulation'. The 500 dollar bills The last 500 dollar bill printing wasn't until 1969 and this decision reflected what I am talking about.... basically less than a decade when common usage types of coins/bills (to some extent, obviously not in common use everywhere for everyone) being so out of use that they became obsolete. After 1969, even hundreds (except for use in getting to other countries, as it is the favored unit when traveling to exchange for $$$ in crisp, new bills) became less common as a usage to most people.</p><p><br /></p><p>I believe that had Kennedy not died and immediately been given the half to commemorate him, there would have been a full debasement of metal in the Franklin half in 1965 and at some point, that unit may have ceased to be coined.</p><p><br /></p><p>Sometimes a person's death coming at just the 'right' time can make a huge difference in many other things. We now have to suffer having dollar and half coins basically only being minted (since 2002 for the Kennedy Half) to keep up production. None of them are being minted for circulation, though of course you do find them being circulated at times. We also have to suffer with coins like the small dollar coins. The only bright spot in continuing the larger issues is that the Ike was made. It has some character.[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>
[QUOTE="Kasia, post: 3267845, member: 31533"]As with many things, there were a number of factors going into this. The Franklin half was not that old, having only started in 1948 and so should still have had a number of years into it before the design was changed. If it had continued, I think that even with silver producing states opposition, that the half would have also gone with the no silver in 1965 and we would not have this discussion. Just like the Washington Quarter or the Roosevelt Dime, a change to silver would not have caused any problem. Silver older halves would have continued to be pulled because of the change, but minting more halves would have let it be ok. However, JFK was assasinated in late Nov, 1963, and there was a rush job to put him on coinage. So much so, and also the fact that Franklin was not the most popular real person on coins at that time and he had never been a president, compelled the halves to be the one to be changed. First mintings of JFK halves came in January 1964. That is fast, to have less than two months from someone dying to having his image on a major US coin. Also, there was not any public notice (forewarning around 1963, early 1964 to the general populace) that coins would lose the silver in 1965. Couple that with the reasoning that the Kennedy coins were also being hoarded rather than having general usage and the mint not wanting to make the 1964 coins a one-off silver issue (with no silver in any future ones) which could make the entire 1964 minting a waste of their time and effort. They still probably(my speculation) thought they could get past the hoarding of the first year issue and that halves would continue to circulate freely. But, in 1965-1972, these were the first years where that would not happen. And I don't think it was simply because of the Franklin half being changed. These were years that because the mint also removed mintmarks to discourage collecting and years where the larger bills and larger coins were less in favor for general usage. Fifty cents was no longer a big deal to people and it was much easier to simply use quarters instead of halves. It became a rarity to even contemplate seeing a 500 or 1000 dollar bill also. The last 1000 dollar bill had been printed in 1945 and so just over time it would have caused those not to be much in 'circulation'. The 500 dollar bills The last 500 dollar bill printing wasn't until 1969 and this decision reflected what I am talking about.... basically less than a decade when common usage types of coins/bills (to some extent, obviously not in common use everywhere for everyone) being so out of use that they became obsolete. After 1969, even hundreds (except for use in getting to other countries, as it is the favored unit when traveling to exchange for $$$ in crisp, new bills) became less common as a usage to most people. I believe that had Kennedy not died and immediately been given the half to commemorate him, there would have been a full debasement of metal in the Franklin half in 1965 and at some point, that unit may have ceased to be coined. Sometimes a person's death coming at just the 'right' time can make a huge difference in many other things. We now have to suffer having dollar and half coins basically only being minted (since 2002 for the Kennedy Half) to keep up production. None of them are being minted for circulation, though of course you do find them being circulated at times. We also have to suffer with coins like the small dollar coins. The only bright spot in continuing the larger issues is that the Ike was made. It has some character.[/QUOTE]
Your name or email address:
Do you already have an account?
No, create an account now.
Yes, my password is:
Forgot your password?
Stay logged in
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Coin Chat
>
40% silver.
>
Home
Home
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Forums
Forums
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Posts
Competitions
Competitions
Quick Links
Competition Index
Rules, Terms & Conditions
Gallery
Gallery
Quick Links
Search Media
New Media
Showcase
Showcase
Quick Links
Search Items
Most Active Members
New Items
Directory
Directory
Quick Links
Directory Home
New Listings
Members
Members
Quick Links
Notable Members
Current Visitors
Recent Activity
New Profile Posts
Sponsors
Menu
Search
Search titles only
Posted by Member:
Separate names with a comma.
Newer Than:
Search this thread only
Search this forum only
Display results as threads
Useful Searches
Recent Posts
More...