I read a few threads about this error prior to auction, after scoping them at pre-auction. I think they are worth more than price paid of about $24/per after tax and fees!
I'm pretty sure die cracks on Peace Dollars are fairly common. I love the design but that's as far as I go with Peace Dollars. That one on the top right, looks like it may have been in a coin canister, like the dime holder in the pics. Not to worry, I've been wrong before. good luck!
The top left one certainly looks like it's got a die crack through TRVST, at least to me. The top right one appears to have a circular scratch. It looks like it's dug into the coin's surface, rather than raised. I can't tell what's going on with the mark on the left side of the bottom coin because of the lighting. The top left and bottom coins look to me like they've been polished. The top right one still seems to have luster.
Yes, unfortunately I think you may be right. If those two are polished, nobody will want to buy them and they will only bring you the price of silver, jmho. Yo i2i, do you have a link on the error you read about?
Nice common die cracks but in my opinion, you overpaid. In my area these would all be in the junk silver dollar pile which is currently at $17.00 per coin.
