I got back into collecting in 09 and purchased the 2011 when it was released. From reading this thread and other sites, I will probably pass on the 2012. Besides, I dont pay much attention to my U.S. coins anymore. Bad enough I have 13 coins I still need to upgrade and would rather blow the money on other area's of coinage then U.S.
I think i'll pass, since they cost more than a free subscription to a coin magazine. I have the 2011 red-book and think i will wait till 2014 to get a new one.