Pretty sure these are both unplated zinc Lincoln Cents. The 1995-D is 100%. 1986-D is a common looking unplated penny and has seen a lot of circulation! 1995-D is maybe the most wild unplated penny I've ever seen! And is uncirculated!
There is a big difference between unplated, and plating removed. The 1st one has had the plating removed. The 2nd one still looks like it has the plating. Both are damaged. The photos in the above post bear zero resemblance to your coins in the OP.