1938-D Registry Quality NGC Jefferson Nickel--Pick your Poison

Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by Lehigh96, Jul 9, 2019.

?

Which of these 3 coins would you choose for your Registry Collection?

  1. A

  2. B

  3. C

Results are only viewable after voting.
  1. Lehigh96

    Lehigh96 Toning Enthusiast

    Ok, this thread will be a slight variation of a guess the grade. I will present three registry quality 1938-D NGC graded Jefferson Nickels with MS67 on the label, and you must decide which of the three you would add to your Registry Collection.

    A)

    [​IMG]

    B)

    [​IMG]

    C)

    [​IMG]


    Please vote in the attached poll and then explain in the comments why you chose your coin. After a few days, I will post the slab photos for each coin and explain my choice.
     
    CircCam likes this.
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. ddoomm1

    ddoomm1 keep on running

  4. CircCam

    CircCam Douglas Fir...

    C, A a close second.

    I might change my mind and go A depending on the in-hand appeal. Looks like a luster bomb with nice color.

    Explanation... C seems to be the most complete coin out of the three. Nice fields, nice luster, splash of color. A has the most pizzazz of the group but I find the marks a little more distracting. B is a nice coin but doesn’t wow me like the other two.
     
    Morgandude11 and Kasia like this.
  5. Morgandude11

    Morgandude11 As long as it's Silver, I'm listening

    I would definitely pick C. While all of them are beautiful, and nicely struck, with decent, if not full step detail, the toning of C is absolutely spectacular. I would happily own any of the three, as my MS 67 1938 D has original, darker album toning. C just has that refined, rainbow aura. I cannot understand how C did not get the star grade.

    A would be my second choice, as the golden toning is also quite premium, in my view.
     
  6. Kasia

    Kasia Got my learning hat on

    Tough choice... But I think C wins.
     
  7. Inspector43

    Inspector43 70 Year Collector

    A because the fields better represent a new die.
     
  8. Patrick King

    Patrick King I Dont Know Nuffin

    C for me, is that a D/D im seeing?
     
  9. FrankHKP7

    FrankHKP7 Active Member

    C. Has a cleaner look, toning is subtle. The hit on the steps is a drag, but nothing I consider a distraction that would drive me toward A or B.
     
  10. Eric Babula

    Eric Babula Member

    C for me. It looks like there's not too much difference in the marks between the three that would sway me toward or away from any one of them. But, I'm partial to the toning on C, over the other two.
     
  11. robec

    robec Junior Member

    C for me also.......A for second choice..
     
  12. Santinidollar

    Santinidollar Supporter! Supporter

    C for me. Moderate, nice slight tone. Solid coin.
     
  13. RonSanderson

    RonSanderson Supporter! Supporter

    If I win do I get to keep it?

    B. I like the superior detail. The jaw has a smooth strike without the residual planchet marks that are so common. Monticello has nice detailing in all the windows and gives an impression of sharpness over the entire reverse.

    On A I like the color but it is uneven on the reverse. C just doesn’t have the crispness of B.
     
    Last edited: Jul 9, 2019
  14. Razz

    Razz Critical Thinker

    B works for me. Less marks on the obverse cheek and hair than A and no spots on the reverse as on C.
     
  15. Evan8

    Evan8 A Little Off Center

    This was difficult for me. With A, i like gold toning on any coin.
    With B the steps were fuller but seemed to have a flat spot on Jefferson's cheek bone i didnt like.
    C is what I chose because it is overall, much more free of marks and has hints of the typical pastel toning. It was the clearer choice for me if I were doing a registry.
     
  16. Dave Waterstraat

    Dave Waterstraat dave700x -1883 O nut

    I like B myself. It appears to be the cleanest..
     
  17. ddddd

    ddddd Member

    I went with B as it seemed to be the cleanest overall (as a few others mentioned).

    C appears to have the nicest color, but it also seems to be the one with the most marks in the jaw area, it has a hit around the ear area, and I believe I see some spots in the center of the Monticello building. If C didn't have two of those three features, I'd expect it would grade higher and be the clear cut choice.

    A also has some marks on the jaw/cheek area and what I believe to be breaks in the golden toning on the reverse.
     
  18. Pickin and Grinin

    Pickin and Grinin Well-Known Member

    I went with A. I felt that the surfaces were the best on that one, would have been with C except the luster under the steps seemed to be muted. I thought that the die state was distracting, also the distracting mark in the steps really caught my eye. Over all I liked the color. It has the look that I would be interested in, in a 67'. But,
    Jeff's jaw and collar also appear to have much more roll contact, Thank God someone decided to stack this one.

    A is still my choice it is the most appealing, smooth and even luster over the entire coin, it has more planchet roughness but the high points of the surfaces look the best.
     
  19. thomas mozzillo

    thomas mozzillo Well-Known Member

    C. I'm not sure if it was your registry set I looked at. If it was, then C fits better with the rest of the set
     
  20. R_rabbit

    R_rabbit Well-Known Member

    :)
    “A” for me . I love that golden tone.

    “C” has great details. Almost rainbow toning.

    “B” looks nice but doesn’t stand out for me. Maybe because he doesn’t have any legs left to stand on;)
     
  21. littlehugger

    littlehugger Active Member

    I like A even though I dont like toning.
    Usually.
    It seems the toning brings out the details and emphasizes the quality of the clean lines and clear fields.
    Nickels, for various reasons, seem to very often have nicks and scratches in the field. This was especially bad in recent ones. Many times, going thru rolls, I would see a beautiful, shiny new one, with a big scratch or nick in the field in front of Jeffersons face.
    So, A is my choice.
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page