1934 Peace GTG

Should I dust off my Trophy shelf Paddy?
I want to say they graded this more conservative due to the rarity of the date

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

No trophy just bragging rights.... I personally would give it a 64+ in hand .

 

Paddy, I think u may want to send that in for 're-consideration! I'm sure it would be worth it, similar to the '27 peace I just picked up

 

If you bought it slabbed, you did great. If you sent it in yourself, you got robbed! That has the look of at least a 64+.

 

You like her huh? Nice strike only a hit over her eye.
I picked up a sweet 1853 arrow half dine today for $20.
I already have one but it had nice clashes on the reverse .

 

I purchased this slabbed.....and very reasonable to boot.

 

Upright and very nice.
Much sweeter than the original images.

 

I'm having a hard time with those images. From what I'm seeing, 63.

 

I think the obverse is 64 close to 64+/5. Its the reverse that would keep it at 63, maybe +

 

I wish I could send my coins to some of you guys (and gals) to get graded. Very generous grades!

 

The coin was purchased slabbed, it is truly under graded by 1 to 2 points. There's nothing generous about this coin other then I got a great deal on it.

 

I think he means because some people gave it a 66 and 65.

 

I came late to this party, but would have guessed 63. It is a fair strike, and the reverse isn't that clean. No way it touches 64. It isn't "truly under graded by 1 to 2 points."

 

That's your option ,and again you are in titled to it. But would of,should of,could of.....are all pointless after the grade has been posted. And again the images are not the best I admit,however in hand this is no less than a 64.

 

I beg to differ. The reverse looks nothing like a 64. Anything in hand looks better---you asked for opinions and you got one. If you don't want opinions, don't post GTG postings, and then get ticked off because people don't agree with you. The reverse shows a poor strike, and has lots of chatter on it, so as to preclude a 64 grade. They got it right.

 

Again late for the party bringing only hot air and a know it all attitude .

 

Someone has a really bad attitude. I gave specifics as to why it isn't a high grade uncirculated coin, and they are quite specific, and founded on knowledge, and appearance of the coin. Doesn't matter to me, as the coin is a 63, no matter how much you want it otherwise. Want a 64? Then go buy a 64. lol

 

I'm surprised it only got a 63. I think that one's under graded. I'd have gone 64.

 

I'm in the 63 camp. Too much going on in the cheek/chin area for the 64.

'dude

 

Here's why I voted 63