It could go either way - A normal Lincoln cent collector wouldn't want it for his 23-S slot, because of the planchet lamination, so it would be valued at a discount from the normal 23-S. However, if there is a Lincoln Cent error collector who needs that date for his lamination set, or to put in the '23-S Error' hole in his collection, they might pay a small premium for it.
Yeah thats what i was thinking. But assuming an error collector would want it what would a reasonable price to sell it for be? 5$?
As a 23-S, I'd think a bit more than $5, but no more than $10, imo.......... It's one of those 'willing buyer/willing seller' situations.