Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="mralexanderb, post: 365773, member: 7851"]Here's what he's worth  John McIntosh may have done right by you in the past but he had that 1921 Peace $ marked at $410 for all to see and buy. The photos I posted were taken by me and not altered in any respect. The first ones were under incandescent light and the 2nd set in sunlight. Granted the coins looked almost flawless in hand and in the pictures. As an experienced collector/dealer, he had to know what he was selling. Other dealers at that show didn't hesitate to tell me that it wasn't a MS 63 coin but an AU coin. Everyone at CoinTalk that responded to my "What's it worth?" thread said it was AU.  So, how trustworthy is Mr. McIntosh and his son? In earlier posts here I explained why I bought it for a high price. But that doesn't explain why he misrepresented the coin and sold it for twice what it's worth. To me, the answer is obvious, GREED. You may still have utmost confidence in him & still think he's trustworthy, but I can only go on my own experience with him and his son. I'll NEVER buy anything from him and I would dissuade anyone else from buying from him. In my opinion he is DISHONEST. Bruce[/QUOTE]