I'm not a fan of uneven wear. I'd grade it on the low end of good because of appeal, but should still be able to expect around $15-20. People might pay less if the date is truly that hard to read. Great find though
The OP's penny I'd grade VG. The date appears to be struck through grease, which will actually hurt the value in this case. I'd value it at G+. I'd grade Fish's Penny as an MS-68 RD.