Found this the other day for scrap price. Pretty beat up but nonetheless it is a 1897 S Barber! Now my question is if I ever sent it in to get graded as part of a lot it would probably come back detailed because of the scratches correct? Just making sure!
Well, that's a score. Even at FR2 (my considered grade; obverse is too nice for P01) it's probably still a Details coin due to the reverse. Not that you should dump it as a result.
I agree with calling it a DETAILS coin. But I think it has a reasonable shot at being an AG-03. Why? Because a LOT more weight is given to the obverse when grading. Yes, the reverse is probably a FR-02. But the obverse is probably a G-04.