That would be enough to keep me away , Also the weakness around the hair at the bottom of Liberty's hat bothers me . I wouldn't bid . Unless he can send you some clear pics , even then I'd be wary . rzage
The straight on pics show all. Fingerprints on the obverse at 3 o'clock. It looks like it was dipped a lot.
You almost have to expect fingerprints on one of the sides since the pics you posted in your opening of this thread showed someone holding the coin by it's edge with bare fingers.