Not exactly an expert on coins. Would be nice to get some opinions on this one though. Thanks in advance. -Mike
I wish I knew who Charles B Tate was. I'm sure his markings have done nothing but decrease the value?
Actually , though the stamping looks almost modern , it may be a counterstamp as some merchants used to put there name on coins for advertisement . Hope someone who knows more about these can tell you if it's old or modern . If old it will have a premium .
It is an authentic 1807 50c piece, if that was what you were implying. Handed to me from my 94 y/o grandmother( still living).
No , not implying that at all . The coin is definitely real . I was talking of the counterstamp . I just looked up Chas Tate and came up empty . Though the name could have been for a lot of things , usually it was for advertisement . Nice Bust half BTW .
So did most of us . Heck up until as late as the '70s some said to clean your coins . A definite no no now . Your lucky it was a common 1922 dollar and not an 1807 Half .
Your 1884-O Morgan had a mintage of 9,730,000 so is quite common in that grade . But being from your Grandparents it's priceless as a family heirloom . Any other coins . Your 1807 half is intriguing though , especially if you can find out who stamped it .
It does seem odd to me that the Morgan is in "worse" shape than the 1807. Being Almost 80 years difference. I googled his name, and found a man in 1875 from Missourri but not much about him. My grandmother is originally from Iowa, currently residing in Maryland. Interesting how It travels
She has 3 total all stamped by the same man. This seemed to be the best of the 3 condition-wise, to my untrained eye. Anyways, she's been curious to see how much she could fetch for one. I told her I'd list one on eBay for her, as I'm already a baseball card fanatic/collector/seller.
I just bid it up a little . I collect Bust halves anyways , but I sould check the Overton # as most of us collect by die marriages . But others would be more interested in the counterstamp . Now to find out who he is or was .
The current bid on Ebay of the half is right now is pretty good considering that there are two days left and the coin is holed, the counterstamp may add a small premium though, not sure how it works though. http://www.ebay.com/itm/271854057764?ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1555.l2649&rmvSB=true Right now at $60, good luck with auction, I have a feeling it will go above $100.
Thanks for all the input guys. I'm not nearly expecting what everyone else on eBay seems to have their half listed as. 5-900$ seems a bit out of the question to me. Was the hole originally made to be worn around a necklace?
Probably, I see a lot of old coins that have been holed for some reason or another. Those $500-$900 listing are for problem free coins, I could see your coin going for $200. Without the hole or the counterstamp it would be around $500, graded around VF-Details. If I had enough money I would definitely place a bid on your coin, it's the kind of thing I would normally buy.
Mike can you ask your Grandmother the history of the Bust half , like when she got them and when they were counter stamped ?