1748 8 Reales chance it is counterfeit?

Discussion in 'World Coins' started by BalamSmith, Aug 6, 2020.

  1. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    Brand new collector here. I was hoping to get some opinions on whether or not this 1748 8 Reales coin is real or counterfeit. From what I've seen online, there are some counterfeits floating around and I have no idea how to tell. I'm very new to this. Tips and pointers would be greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance.

    20200806_153404.jpg 20200806_153337.jpg 20200806_153131.jpg 20200806_153150.jpg 20200806_153201.jpg 20200806_153207.jpg 20200806_153436.jpg 20200806_153457.jpg
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. chuckylucky5

    chuckylucky5 Supporter! Supporter

    Looks genuine to me. Mexico 8 Reales, KM#104.1
     
    BalamSmith likes this.
  4. fretboard

    fretboard Defender of Old Coinage!

    Surface looks casted but it could be real, I'll let the experts chime in! :cigar:
     
    BalamSmith likes this.
  5. medoraman

    medoraman Supporter! Supporter

    I am leery. I usually concentrate on the globe map, and not a fan of this one at all. Looks cast/very porous. Any chance its sea salvage?

    Btw, where did you get it sir? There are a lot more than a "few counterfeits" around. Tens of thousands if not millions really. One of the MOST counterfeited coins. I probably own 10 by accident from group lots, (knew they were fake when bought).
     
    longshot likes this.
  6. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    I actually got it for trade. It was part of a group lot that I traded a few items for. So there's really no way of telling what the value is to me. I made my money off of the other items, so I'm not really losing anything if it is counterfeit, but was really hoping otherwise.
     
  7. medoraman

    medoraman Supporter! Supporter

    Weigh it. Should be telling. If I saw this coin I would assume its false unless I could be proven otherwise. If you gave me a weight too light for the issue the issue would be settled for me.
     
    serafino likes this.
  8. johnmilton

    johnmilton Well-Known Member

    I was hoping that it might be a sea savage piece from the reverse, but the obverse looks to be an obvious cast copy.

    I don't have any sea salvage pieces, but I do have a counterfeit and a genuine example.

    This is a cast counterfeit. Note the pits in the sufaces and the raised dots of metal in the fields.

    1760 Fake Pillar Dollar O.jpg 1760 Fake Pillar Dollar R.jgp.jpg

    This is a genuine piece. Note the smooth surfaces and crisp, sharp devices.

    1763 Pillar Dollar O.jpg 1763 Pillar Dollar R.jpg
     
    Last edited: Aug 6, 2020
    serafino, BalamSmith and medoraman like this.
  9. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    I will do that asap (don't have a scale right now) Would it be a good idea to have maybe a jeweler to test its fineness as well or would that be a bad idea? I really am very new at this. I really appreciate you taking the time for this. Thank you
     
  10. johnmilton

    johnmilton Well-Known Member

    It's bad idea for a couple of reasons. First, if you have to pay him or her, it's waste of money. I am pretty sure that it's bad. Second, if it were genuine, they would damage it in some way that would lower the value.

    If you drop acid on it and get dark spot, that's not good. If you take a chunk out of genuine piece, that's much worse.
     
  11. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    The pits were one of the reasons I thought it might be counterfeit as well. There was another site that had listed that as a possible sign of a counterfeit. Either that or sea salvage, just like you have said.
     
  12. PaulTudor

    PaulTudor Well-Known Member

    If you are new to collecting, then 8 reales is a very tough area for a beginner, so you need to be very careful and learn/research a lot before purchasing one.
     
    serafino likes this.
  13. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    I see that now. There is a lot more to it than I thought. Luckily, it really didn't cost me any cash. The other stuff I got with it made up for my trade. I have a long ways before I'm fully ready, but I really thank you guys for helping me along the way.
     
    PaulTudor likes this.
  14. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    Looks like it weighs nearly 18.5g. I'm pretty sure that's a bit underweight, yes?
     
  15. medoraman

    medoraman Supporter! Supporter

    More than a bit. That is only 2/3rd the intended weight. Its a pot metal counterfeit. You can go to any Asian flea market and find them today, these and US, British, and French trade dollars. Every one I have ever been to has them for sale, (wife is asian).
     
    serafino and johnmilton like this.
  16. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    Okay, thank you! I really appreciate it. Even though it's counterfeit, now I know.
     
  17. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    Thank you everyone for your help. Even though it's counterfeit, at least I didn't lose any money on it. You guys are awesome. Thanks again!
     
    serafino, John Conduitt and PaulTudor like this.
  18. medoraman

    medoraman Supporter! Supporter

    No problem sir. This is why we come here. As long as new members ask honest questions, and will listen to our answers, we love helping out new members. I just hope this hasn't hurt your love of coin collecting.
     
    serafino and BalamSmith like this.
  19. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    Not at all. As a matter of fact, it makes me want to continue even more so that I can recognize things like this. This time may not have cost me anything but who knows what would have happened in the future.
     
  20. lordmarcovan

    lordmarcovan Numismatic jack of all trades & specialist in none Moderator

    These can be tricky since the sea-salvaged ones can sometimes resemble the fakes.

    Welcome to the forums. Stick around.
     
  21. BalamSmith

    BalamSmith New Member

    Thank you. I will. All the support I have gotten. Thank you
     
    serafino and lordmarcovan like this.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page