I wonder if it was over dipped as the luster looks muted . If the luster is there I'd give her a 63 . Though techniquely I'd go AU-58 .
OK , I got it . :)
That narrows it down considerably . ;)
Hey Paddy , these are foreign coins correct ?
Way to go ole man . Great contest .
I think it's a solid 66 from the ANA Grading Standards . I don't think it would gold CAC but should get a green for it's nearly mark free fields ,...
Maybe he's keeping us in suspense .;)
The Busty would detail , the others I can't tell with the pics but I lean that they're all in detail slabs .
I agree , it's about a 64 . Kind of hard to tell with those pics though .
I don't blame you , if he quoted you a price for all the coins and you accepted it sounds like a done deal . If he's a close friend and you want...
AU details , I like Kirkuleez's idea of carrying it around to make an honest EF out of it . Just wondering if those cleaning lines are as bad in...
What mark are you saying would have got this coin body bagged . I just don't see it where it ever would have been body bagged . JMHO
No premium , especially on such a common and low grade MS coin .
I like what Jello and Paul said . PL coins tend to show off marks more . I also think it was market graded up a point as these are usually...
Nice coin , I have a slab in the same condition .
If it were mine I'd use the Intercept Shield slab holders and then the slab holder storage box . It may be overkill , for such a nice coin it...
I'd think with proper storage , silica gels and other precautions it should be fine . But I'm not a chemist so maybe Bad Thad or Desert Gem could...
I can't believe NGC gave it a 68 with those polish lines . But an amazing coin .
I'll go 63 , but it's a guess because of your pics , which BTW are better than mine .
Good write up . I really have to get back on track and finish my set , sans early dollars , I'm going up to 1/2 dollars with one Seated dollar to...
Separate names with a comma.
