I'm in the blister camp.
They are common, except for higher UNC grades: https://coinappraiser.com/coins/value-of-1924-peace-silver-dollar/
You need to have a "special" person that you can contact to report items and usually EBay listens to and acts on their requests. We, from the...
Well, if the "grading" AI is as accurate as "siri" or any of the other programs that are in computers or answering services, then I'd say stand by...
Except for the marks on the '25, I'd say that it was AU. The '24, I'd say low XF.
And then put the coin in a glass of Coca Cola for a week, changing often and see what happens.
I agree with the glue/tape theory and whatever in the adhesive removed the finish/oxide.
They just look to me like a normal circulated coin that someone polished with a buffer, hitting the high spots.
OK, I'll bite .... I went back about as far as my eyes would take me. What, exactly is a CirCam? I'll guess that it's a kind of cameo appearance...
Your lowest mintage for your 3 is 5 billion coins. All will only be worth 1 cent, ever.
The penny photos just show a tired, worn die. You have to be careful looking at the CaC "variety" section. There is a semi-correct actual...
With the wear, both sides, I'd say VF-30
Yes, loose in the die for MD. Vicky has been doubled by MD on many dates and denominations.
It's amazing how much BS shows up lately on EBay.
With those photos, you can't see any anomalies.
I don't think that another half dollar would fit the "clip" correctly. It's not a complete, linear arc.
I'm in the corrosion camp and someone trying to remove the crap left.
To me, the curvature of the clip is not linear.
Could it be a die clash from the wheat stem? Your link shows a couple just like it, but die cracks usually aren't that wide.
Well, I haven't got LordM's yet, but I DO have about 50 1919's, with 4 of them with the offsets for 4 of the 6 letters, and 2 of them all the way...
Separate names with a comma.