I personally prefer #3, but I love toned coins.
67*
I'll go with MS65 5FS
MS67 6FS
PCGS grading Jefferson's: MS64 FS What I think the actual grade should be MS64
Just a beat up common 41P nickel. Worth $0.05
67
67+
66
66 5FS
65
66+ 5FS
#2, mainly for the full steps
I would say that it will come back MS 66 5FS from NGC based upon your pictures. If it comes back 67 then it is because the face and collar were...
F Details: Damage
AU50
MS67 5FS. Very Nice Jefferson, both of them. The one I have in my NGC registry set (Gileshokie) is an MS67. There is a slight nick on the steps...
MS66 5FS. 41D are usually very well struck with many of them having nice steps.
Separate names with a comma.