Did they maintain the grade assigned by ICG?
HAVE YOU SENT IT TO NGC YET?!?!?!?!?
As Mikenoodle pointed out, make sure you price it as a Type II. The Type I is a lot more expensive, but unfortunately you don't have that one.
I agree with these guys that it's a PO-1.
Yes, I'm sure it has an old cleaning. However, the OLD cleanings are usually overlooked by the TPGs. I think it would straight grade at EF 40.
Have you contacted them, and are they going to reholder it for free?
I definitely see the die clash in the 1951. I'm not seeing it in the others.
MS 67 RD
"Buy the coin, not the slab."
I just checked out a book on these from the ANA library, and it makes the claim the coins were unpopular. To add credibility to the argument, the...
Eeek!
Are you talking about the old cleaning (it would probably straight grade), or the tiny rim ding at about 8:30? Given the age, I'm convinced it...
Wow...I'm not following the consensus here. Even after all these mid-mint state guesses, I'm convinced I can see the slightest trace of wear on...
Check out the harsh cleaning on this Trade Dollar: https://denver.craigslist.org/clt/6450520567.html I contacted the seller and he claims it was...
Yep, that was the place. I came in the day after (Sunday) not having heard about it. I was traveling for my military duties and just asked Siri...
Those are nice!
I bought this in a coin store in Phoenix yesterday. I'm grading it around AU-50, maybe AU-55 on a good day. What caught my attention was the...
Wouldn't you know it, the ANA has a copy at the library...15 miles from my work!!! **Reserved**
I'm a big fan of the phrase, "buy the book before the coin." So, can anyone recommend a good book on the Woods Hibernia series?
VF-20 with an old cleaning?
Separate names with a comma.
