Here's the issue: Does the nick on the jaw cause an issue with grade? ie does it keep it from MS64 or not? I don't know. So I'll guess a YES to...
No bean on the dime. jom
Gold: No bean jom
Green jom
It's hard to tell as I can't see why it's an MS62. Trueview's just don't cut it for me....they always seem to make the coin look "unreal"....
Here ya go. Yes to the Bean. Since I bought this coin with the sticker I can't add anything. The strike through didn't seem to bother CAC so...
OK, I'll go again. PCGS XF40 [ATTACH]
[ATTACH] OK, I guess we are done. Anyway, the coin has a green sticker. I've discussed this coin with several dealers and most think the...
Next up: 1834 $5 PCGS XF45 [ATTACH]
OK, who's next....I have one once we are ready. jom
1869: Gold CAC jom
I see hairlines in the fields with the bottom left photo. Could be die polishing though. I haven't a clue. This is the main reason I've never...
OK, here goes. The coin FAILED at CAC. I did speak to JA about it and he mentioned that there was rubbing on the knee of liberty. Something...
Suggestion: If you have a respones to this (either way) give the reason why you think so. It's helpful...at least to me. :) jom
Really? Okie dokie... I bought this coin 9/20/2008 in a PCGS 65 holder. I sent this coin to CAC 12/11/2012. What happened? [ATTACH] jom PS:...
OK...who's next? jom
I've actually talked to JA about some of my failures (4 different times maybe) and pretty much every time some coin failed due to "an old...
1839-O: I'm going to go out on a limb here as say it failed the Green bean. My guess is that they thought it was cleaned and retoned. Often...
I think you know that CAC ignores the "+" so they felt that it warranted the AU58 grade. So you are saying they got it correct? But maybe I...
It's hard to tell but I'd guess non-CAC due to lack of luster. I don't collect copper so I could be WAY off here. jom
Separate names with a comma.
