Proofs are tough. I don't see any issues here but others think there might be problems. I don't know. I'll guess GREEN on this one. jom
Green on the CBH. jom
Photos can certainly have something to do with it. Luster and, many times, eye appeal might not show in a photo. Marks and strike can mostly be...
I sent this in in July 2015 and it received a Green Bean. There is some hint in the photo of some under-lying luster which, IMO, gave it the 58...
PCGS AU58[ATTACH]
Maybe it's the photo but the coin looks dipped with luster left. I don't know here...tough one. Maybe it's just I expect some toning on this...
Let's face it. It is exceedingly difficult to grade anything with just a photo. Sure, strike and surfaces (partly) can be judged with a photo....
Bizzaro World! I guess one needs to see the coin in hand but from the photo it looked at the very least worse case no-brainer Green. Weird. Who...
GOLD. The coin looks MS. jom
OK, who's next? jom
Maybe a luster bump as well....you'd have to see in hand though. It's tough with just a photo. Also, it eventually got a "PCGS color bump" as...
OK, it's been 24 hours so I'll post. In what is sure to be a surprise this coin received a GOLD sticker (it was a bit of a surprise to me at the...
Okie dokie. My "avatar" coin: PCGS MS66 [ATTACH] jom
Green on the 51 gold. jom
I have another but I'll wait until, say, tomorrow night so someone else can go. jom
Well, PCGS didn't see it either but that's what my notes on this tell me (notes taken while on phone with JA). At the time I just assumed that it...
Sorry....been busy. My bad. I sent the coin into CAC in July of 2015 and it FAILED. My notes say JA told me the reverse was "buffed". And...
OK, I'll go. PCGS AU55 [ATTACH] jom
THat's actually a pretty good strike for the coin. Green Bean....of course I assume than the slab photo is pre-submission. The coin does look...
Yes, if people are convinced of the superiority of PCGS most correctly graded coins in NGC holders will get cracked out leaving the mistakes....
Separate names with a comma.
