What do you mean by “glaring inconsistencies”? Are there specific examples that you can recall within those Morgan’s? I know that with toners...
I’ve enjoyed following this thread. Previously my assumption has been that ICG graded coins trade for less due to the fact that they are...
The tooling on the Standing Liberty would be much more of a deal breaker for me than the over-aggressive cleaning on the Bar Copper. At least...
I upgraded my seated quarter from a weakly struck AU50 to this sharply struck PF61. Under normal daylight the hairlines aren’t that apparent. A...
I came back from my afternoon run today and anxiously looked in my mailbox for a coin I have been expecting. I was disappointed to find only a...
A crisis of confidence could cause one of them to fail. For example, evidence of corruption or major conflict of interest, potentially from a...
When looking at the one pictured in this thread I thought I saw the cardboard holders encased in the plastic slab along with the coins.
I can definitely see the added value of the set pictured here. If I was in the market for an early mint set in original packaging, this would be...
That is also true. Prior to trade dollars, I think seated dollars often went to China as well. But apart from the China trade a lot of gold...
I think we are overlooking the main use, or one of the main uses, of gold coins which was foreign trade. Domestically there was full faith and...
It is my understanding that starting in the late 1870’s, gold, silver and paper money traded at par. Gold dollars had a slight premium for gifts...
You just answered your own question in your statement above. This probably also is the answer to my question of why PCGS didn’t detail it. I’m...
Perhaps it should have been detailed for the improper alloy mix, or slabbed as an error. I can see the argument for the technical grade, for...
I wonder if the coin in the photo that the OP ordered will miraculously show up after he returns the ugly one. Perhaps someone at L&C saw an...
EF details damaged would be my grade, not sure what ICG would have graded it. The gouge in the left field kills it for me.
In my mind, stock photos are for commodity items like ASE’s or generic slabbed Morgan dollars. A slabbed svdb in a specific grade is not that...
Yes, I agree that they could legally claim it. Just like I and other collectors have every right to publicize and complain about such a claim in...
To your last question I would answer no. As for “leftovers”, I have the same impression of old generation PCGS and NGC holders. Most of what I...
What exactly is the perception? Is it that coins in ICG slabs are overgraded? Inconsistently graded? Assigned numerical grades that should have...
The name “Sergei” is spelled in Ukrainian. I think the second word in the line above it is «князу» (prince). It doesn’t seem like it should be of...
Separate names with a comma.
