115 The reverse really pops, but the obverse looks a bit more splotchy...I still like it!
I agree; I have stopped (the original paging was from early on; the thread started in July).
The photos are pretty accurate...on the reverse there are a few lines that might be from a light cleaning or die polish lines (they can only be...
Update: no bean! CAC didn't like it even as a 55!
625 ...the scratch does not look that bad Thanks @Santinidollar
AU 58...looks nice enough to be MS 63 on a good day
@baseball21 what is guide for a straight graded Fine (i.e. F12)?
PCI -> MS 63 My take -> AU 55 Some PCI holders are decent or even accurate, but the gold ones are fairly often too high.
Buffalo Nickels sure aren't as simple as Morgans when it come to grading! I will go with my first impression: MS 64
I agree that Buffalo Nickels are hard to grade. I would not be surprised with anything between AU and MS....I will go with my first impression: MS 63
Points Table ron_c - 3 Points KSorbo - 1 Point IBetASilverDollar - 1 Point charlietig - 1 Point Beefer518 - 1 Point jwitten - 1 Point ddddd - 1...
I sold it for $57 so @baseball21 barely nudges out @ron_c ..that person then put it up on ebay raw and made another $10-$15; I later saw it from...
Points Table ddddd - 8 Points Beefer518 - 7 Points baseball21 - 6.5 Points brg5658 - 6 Points IBetASilverDollar - 5 Points heavycam.monstervam - 5...
200 ...nice color on a popular type coin!
This one can go in either the toning thread or here. I will say that it sold for less than a straight graded toner, so I will post it to this...
Nice set! And not easy to have them match so well. Congrats!
You don't need to post your own coin if you do win. So go ahead and partake!
MS 63 ..nice color!
300 I will say about half of guide, assuming that you received a bargain. I would think that you could easily sell it for a good profit.
Points Table ron_c - 3 Points KSorbo - 1 Point IBetASilverDollar - 1 Point charlietig - 1 Point Beefer518 - 1 Point jwitten - 1 Point
Separate names with a comma.
