Beautiful. And a solid 5 in my book.
If those pics are accurate then I’d say 5. But I am not a fan of PCGS TrueView images because the saturation is almost always off and the...
4 for me also - for the reasons Lehigh stated. If this type of "wow" toning were on the obverse and on more of the coin it would be 5 to high 5!...
@dddd and @Morgandude11 and @physics-fan3.14 : I have a couple more I'd like to post eventually, but I think @physics-fan3.14 was going to post next?
I would have also said 3. Sorry for slow reply.
1892 GB Half Crown PCGS OGH MS64 I also never take full slab pics of coins. Too much wasted real estate; I collect coins, not plastic.
My score was a 4 on the proposed scale, so in agreement.
Hope a non-USA coin is okay. [IMG] [IMG]
As clad coins go, this has good toning. But I’m with the others, particularly the comment about the condition (looks pretty worn for an MS63...
Attached is my example - sadly not gold ;) [IMG]
Not a rare coin at all, but super hard to find in uncirculated condition. This one is graded MS64 by PCGS, and I purchased it in 2016. [IMG]
That 1939-D Lincoln Cent is a solid 4 for me. It's pushing my threshold of personal preferences and approaching a 5. Superb coin Jason!
I'm in the "4" camp.
Here are a few examples of photos where I have included edge markings in the composite images. [IMG] [IMG] [IMG]
Firstly, let me say, @Denis Richard your photos are superb. And I love the subsequent processing of the coin images into whimsical backgrounds,...
I'd say 3. IMO the market tends to prefer smoother transitions of toning, than the "sharp edge" transitions. It's still a lovely coin, just not...
While I find the images by the OP here to be exceptional in their artistic value, we have to be careful where we toe the line of coin photography...
Oh, trust me, I can read. I guess I should have said "it's a pity that Morgans are the coins that are called Monsters"....I thought it was always...
I'd go with a 3 for Lehigh's most recent post. Not enough coverage of the coin/design for a 4 or higher. An aside: It's a pity this thread is...
[IMG]
Separate names with a comma.
