As soon as I saw the new photos only one word came to my mind-Polished. It's also toning a steel blue and that adds to the shine.
I like the darker one, the one on the left at AU-58. Nice detail and a hint of the original red. The shiny one is too banged up for me but it...
Looks like a nice counterfeit 1 oz bullion coin.
That's a cool looking error! Has a date and it looks like it is shaped like a baseball cap.
While your coin is reflective that does not make it PL.
Nope, I don't drink anything with alcohol. Never even tasted a beer. :)
I stand corrected. Thank you @Oldhoopster I'd swear that said clip. PS, I can't stand the taste of coffee.
Yet another great example. :)
DDD or worthless doubling. Welcome to CT.
The blurry pic doesn't make the Damage go away. Welcome to CT.
Common plating blisters.
Looks like a die crack at the rim but need better photos to be sure.
Damaged and spenders.
That's a great greaser. An extreme example so I'd keep it. Not worth but a few dollars to the right person.
Very nice die clash. Well done!
Not a die clip. A clipis when part of the edge is missing. It is a die chip. Part of the Die broke off and when it's used to strike a planchet it...
Environmental damaged so spend it. Welcome to CT.
Very nice, only a few left to go. Welcome to CT.
Nice offset error. Strange shape but very nice.
What they said. We can't help if we can't see it.
Separate names with a comma.